Sunday, January 25, 2015

The once and future kingdom

if you can keep it:
WAIMANOLO, Hawaii (AP) - Native Hawaiians could be in line for federal recognition similar to many American Indian tribes. But the issue is inflaming distrust between moderates who support the idea and others who want to see the Hawaiian Kingdom restored...
The federal government is now mulling a relationship with Hawaiians that could protect more than 200 programs and secure millions in federal money. Advocates have been seeking federal recognition for more than a decade.
Hawaiian nationalists insist that the kingdom should be restored. Their dominance of the debate could threaten a proposal that could give Native Hawaiians privileges enjoyed by other native groups. 
While the nationalists perhaps hold the upper hand now, I suspect that they will not succeed, at least in the short term, for two reasons.  The first is that no matter how underhanded the means whereby we stole invited Hawaii to join this union of free states, Uncle Sam has no intention of letting it go.  Like Crimea for the Russians, Hawaii is too critical a base for the projection of sea power to let mere legalities or moralities get in the way.  Hawaii could become a free nation only if the United States could no longer hold it by force, and that's not likely to occur in the short term.

But second is this: Hawaii simply cannot survive on its own.  It is a tourist island that thrives as it does today only because there are lots of people who can afford to dump lots of money on warm weather and flowered shirts.  Any less prosperous or peaceful future will likely not feature an abundance of either. A free Hawaii can expect, at least, to return economically to where it was in the 30s or 40s. A worst case scenario takes it back to the 1890s - idyllic to be sure, but also able to support but a fraction of the population that lives there today.

In the short term, I expect that if anything happens vis-a-vis Hawaii's native people, it will be the 'moderates' who win the day - it's always easier to vote yourself financial benefits than it is to win your independence and all the responsibility that comes therewith. The nationalists, if they are smart, will join the moderates in wringing whatever concessions they can from Uncle Sugar in the short term.  Having your enemy pay as many of your bills as possible makes a much higher base from which to begin the final ascent toward independence.

But though the nationalists might win the day in the end, I suspect they'll be very supprised at how little they actually gain.  Their first order of business will be to discover, I suspect, that any base useful for a big nation to project power from America is a useful base for a big nation to project power toward it.

Perhaps they could coronate their new monarch King Pyrrhus I. If the Chinese will let them, that is.


  1. Whatever they do, they will quickly realize that their leaders are quite happy to let everyone else hang if they can just keep their hand on part of the wad Uncle Sam distributes. The government doesn't have to do much, other than encourage, or more simply allow, the graft that this sort of relationship creates. The tribal leaders will, behind the scenes, keep things in check. Any who think differently, and rise through the ranks on that, will typically back off once they realize how much money and access they really get at higher levels.

    Everything thought to be free comes with a huge cost. If people want to become animals, or slaves, and choose it freely no matter their stated intent, I can't have much sympathy for them. All you have to do is drive through ghettos, or whole cities in some cases... visit reservations... and think, just a bit, about what 'free money' and other such does to peoples.

    As a business men, I see why. As a human, Christian, I see why not. Not my call.

  2. In addition to the tourists, you also have the military presence that dumps a lot into the local economy, specifically on Oahu.