Friday, August 5, 2016

All cancers matter

This made me laugh:
The union representing San Francisco police officers published a photograph of two dogs in its monthly newspaper that critics say belittles the Black Lives Matter movement and raises questions about the police force’s commitment to repairing its relationship with communities of color...

The photo weighs in on a controversy that has flared on social media and has animated political debates. Some people have countered the phrase “Black lives matter” by saying, “All lives matter,” and they in turn have been accused of objecting to a simple request that black people be treated fairly.
I suspect the truth is the opposite. The reason BLM gets so angry about #AllLivesMatter is not that it treats them unfairly, but that it denies them snowflake status. And snowflake status is the currency of social justice.

I was thinking about a comparison the other day.  Lots and lots of people have their favorite cancer. This one is all about breast cancer and the other about ovarian cancer and the third about lung cancer.  And it's all well and good and they get along swimmingly because they all get to be special.

But what if someone were to come along to that happy little group, representing every type of cancer under the sun, and in response to appeals for awareness about this particular cancer or that one, that person just said, #AllCancersMatter.

Do you suppose the breast cancer lady would look around at all the cancers that matter and say, Hmmm...I guess you're right?

Or would she hit the guy with her sign because her mom DIED of breast cancer and HOW DARE you deny my lived experience and erase my pain you bigotsexisthomophobeshitlord?

I suspect the answer would far more often be the second.

It's obvious that if black lives matter and blue lives matter and everyone's lives matter* that All Lives Matter. But that's not why people say it. They are simply saying it because those who request snowflake status under the guise of fairness are so triggered when it is denied.

* except the unborn, because Constitution.

1 comment:

  1. indeed.

    and once you become aware of the pernicious emotional blackmail you'll notice that you see it all the time.

    that's what Khan was doing. Oh noes, my son died in service to the US!

    so what? not everyone who dons the uniform is worthy of respect. say, for instance, Patricia Smith who's son died at Benghazi due to ( at a minimum ) the criminal negligence of Obama and Hillary.

    clearly, his life wasn't deserving of any respect.

    what difference, at this point, does it make?